Skip to main content

Comparison of Withdrawing from Portfolios of SPY and Franklin Income Fund (LU0098860793)

This articlel is about comparing withdrawing from portfolios of just SPY and Franklin Income Fund.

In the other article, I have found that the Franklin Income Fund US version has a smoother upper return slope than SPY which means Franklin Income Fund may be safer without sacraficing too much performance.

Also in this article, I compare the US version and the Luxembourg verions of the Franklin Income Fund, and have found that they have similar performance.

Now, let's find out if the Luxembourg version of Franklin Income Fund serves better than SPY for investors when we need to withdraw a certain amonut every year.

APP

Withdrawal Frequency

Start Date:
Portfolio Value: $
Withdrawal Rate: %

Simulate 100 Times

Retired Right Before 2000 Financial Crisis

You could withdraw up to 10% with Franklin Income Fund and still not be broke now but can do with SPY

Retired Right Before 2008 Financial Crisis

9.5% is the max you could have withdrawn from Franklin Income Fund.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Which is better? BND or AGG?

The US 10-year treasury yield has reached at 2007-2008 years level, which is about 16 years ago. From a technical point of view, it is a buy. Then there are 2 bond ETFs that I am interested in. There are BND and AGG. They are very similar in nature. US 10 year Treasury Bond, chart, prices - FT.com Expense Ratio BND: 0.03% AGG: 0.03% The same. Turnover Rate BND: 40.00% AGG: 104.0% BNG seems better. Historical Performance Comparison Investment duration: 5 years with no tax on dividends BND wins a little with winning rate of 57.5%, but AGG wins 0.012% in return. Investment duration: 5 years with 30% tax on dividends AGG wins a little with winning rate of 65% and a 0.079% difference on average. Investment duration: 10 years with no tax on dividends AGG wins a little with winning rate of 67% and a 0.024% difference on average. Investment duration: 10 years with 30%  tax on dividends AGG wins a little with winning rate of 99% and a 0.095% difference on average. C...
Post a Comment
Read more